Before proposing anything, I ran a thorough audit: Fullstory sessions, funnel metrics, Prime page performance, and a competitive benchmark. I was looking for patterns, not just problems.
What I found was that users weren't rejecting Prime. They were confused by it. The value wasn't landing at the right moment, and the commitment felt too large too early.
Rather than benchmarking travel competitors, who were all making similar mistakes, and looked at a completely different sector: food delivery. Uber One had solved a similar problem elegantly: a simple checkbox at checkout surfacing an instant, contextual saving. No separate page. No forced decision. Just a transparent offer at the right moment.
That cross-industry leap was the unlock. It showed that the solution didn't need to live within the conventions of travel booking. It needed to borrow from somewhere that had already figured out low-friction subscription acquisition.
Benchmark — Uber One checkout checkbox
Benchmark — food delivery membership patterns
Prime is a high-stakes touchpoint. The solution had to work across a complex matrix of user states. Getting it wrong for any of them would mean either missing an acquisition opportunity or creating a frustrating, confusing experience.
I mapped and designed for every relevant scenario: existing Prime members, users who had already used their free trial, users who were logged in vs not, users with price freedom vs without. Each state required a different approach: different messaging, different hierarchy, different CTA logic.
Scenario mapping — user states and corresponding experiences
This was the hardest part of the work: not the concept itself, but making sure the concept held up across every edge case without becoming inconsistent or manipulative.
Because Prime acquisition is one of the most sensitive areas of the business, this proposal required buy-in at every level: product leads, design leadership, and C-level stakeholders. I presented multiple times, always grounding the direction in behavioural data and the benchmark rather than design preference.
The proposal was approved at every level and moved into A/B testing.
Final design — checkout page with Prime checkbox + benefits drawer